What are you looking for ?
Advertise with us
RAIDON

EMC Proposes $1.8 billion to Acquire Data Domain

For $300 million or 20% more than NetApp

EMC Corporation proposed to acquire all of the outstanding common stock of Data Domain, Inc. for $30.00 per share in cash, in a transaction with a total enterprise value of approximately $1.8 billion, net of Data Domain’s cash. EMC’s all-cash offer represents a 20% premium to the cash and stock offer made by NetApp for Data Domain on May 20, 2009.

EMC’s all-cash proposal is superior to the proposed NetApp transaction providing Data Domain stockholders greater value and certainty. EMC’s proposal is not subject to a financing or due diligence contingency, and the company will use existing cash balances to finance the transaction. EMC is promptly commencing a tender offer for all outstanding Data Domain common stock in order to expedite the timing of this transaction. The proposal was unanimously approved by the EMC Board of Directors.

Joe Tucci, EMC Chairman, President and CEO, said: "Strategically, this combination will further enhance our ability to broaden EMC’s best-in-class storage portfolio for the benefit of EMC and Data Domain customers and this, in turn, will accelerate EMC’s top-and bottom-line growth rates. Our substantially superior proposal is a win-win for both companies."

Tucci added: "The combination of EMC and Data Domain technologies will strengthen EMC’s leadership in the fast-growing and very important next-generation disk-based backup and archive market, and will also result in a business larger than a billion dollars for EMC in 2010. We expect the transaction with Data Domain to be accretive to EMC’s 2010 non-GAAP diluted earnings per share."

EMC has made this offer to acquire Data Domain for its fast-growing revenue base, its strong data protection-focused management team and sales force and its highly complementary storage software technology that will help to accelerate both companies’ ability to deliver industry-leading next-generation disk-based backup and archiving solutions for customers.

EMC has retained both external financial and legal advisors to assist it with this transaction.

The full text of the letter that EMC sent to Data Domain’s President and Chief Executive Officer follows below:

June 1, 2009
Mr. Frank Slootman
President and Chief Executive Officer
Data Domain, Inc.
2421 Mission College Boulevard
Santa Clara, California 95054

Dear Frank:

On behalf of EMC, I am pleased to submit to you and your Board of Directors a proposal to acquire Data Domain which is substantially superior to the NetApp proposal. We are highly impressed with your business and your team, and we are confident that a business combination will deliver substantial benefits to your company’s stockholders, customers, employees and partners. We are disappointed that we were not given an opportunity to explore a business combination prior to the announcement of your proposed transaction with NetApp, particularly since I believe you should have been aware of our interest.

EMC proposes to acquire all outstanding Data Domain common stock for $30.00 per share in cash. This price represents a 20% premium to NetApp’s cash and stock offer and is a Superior Proposal as defined in your merger agreement with NetApp. The Board of EMC has unanimously approved this proposal.

EMC’s proposal is not subject to any financing or due diligence contingency, and we will use existing cash balances to finance the transaction.

In order to consummate this transaction quickly, we intend to effect a first step tender offer for all outstanding Data Domain common stock followed by a second step merger for any remaining shares. We are enclosing with this letter a form of agreement to effect our proposed transaction which is substantially identical to the agreement between you and NetApp except as to our superior price and except for changes reflecting our faster two-step structure. We are prepared to execute this agreement immediately upon your Board of Directors’ determination that EMC has made a Superior Proposal as provided in the merger agreement with NetApp. We are utilizing the two-step structure to enable us to pay Data Domain’s stockholders as quickly as possible after signing a definitive agreement, and to further expedite this timing, we are promptly commencing the tender offer. Consistent with the terms of your agreement with NetApp, we expect to follow the process set forth in the Annex to this letter to enter into a signed agreement with Data Domain as quickly as possible.

In comparison to your proposed transaction with NetApp, EMC’s proposal represents a far superior alternative for your stockholders.

  • EMC’s proposal provides higher absolute value for each Data Domain share.
  • As an all cash offer, EMC’s proposal offers greater certainty of value.
  • With a tender offer structure, EMC’s transaction offers a faster time to close.


A transaction with EMC also represents a far more compelling alternative to your customers, employees and partners. For example:

  • The customer use cases for Data Domain’s data deduplication technologies and EMC’s existing data deduplication technologies are generally distinct. The combination of Data Domain’s leading target-based deduplication technologies and EMC’s leading source-based deduplication technologies will allow the combined company to address the broad range of customers’ data protection needs in a unified and complementary way. The marketplace for storage software solutions is complex, dynamic and highly competitive. Having superior deduplication technology solutions that combine the strengths of Data Domain and EMC in this storage software marketplace will help customers better achieve their needs as the market continues to evolve.

  • EMC’s world-class sales organization of approximately 9,000 professionals in over 400 offices around the globe, its extensive network of several thousand partners and its strong relationships with many of the premier enterprises worldwide will dramatically accelerate the deployment of Data Domain’s solutions.

  • The combination of Data Domain’s and EMC’s technologies will provide the basis for the next-generation of disk-based back-up and archiving solutions for customers by providing functionally superior and cost-effective alternatives to tape-based information backup.

  • Next-generation disk-based back-up and archiving solutions represent key enabling technologies for the build-out and customer use of true high-reliability cloud computing infrastructures for both enterprises’ own virtualized data centers (‘private’ clouds) and third party providers (‘public’ clouds).


We will maintain the senior management team under your leadership and operate Data Domain as a product division within EMC. As a part of EMC, Data Domain will have access to EMC’s superior global resources and we will enhance this division with additional EMC technology, products and capital. The combination with EMC represents a unique opportunity for your management team and employees to benefit from the greater resources of EMC and to become important leaders within a larger organization committed to leadership in next-generation information infrastructure solutions.

EMC has a long and distinguished track record of skillfully acquiring and integrating leading technology companies. Because of our considerable experience, I am confident that we can successfully integrate our companies, retain the talented employees of Data Domain and realize the full potential of this combination.

We look forward to executing the definitive agreement attached.

Very truly yours,

/s/ Joseph M. Tucci
Joseph M. Tucci
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer
EMC Corporation


Summary of the Prompt Process
to Enter into a Signed Agreement with EMC

  • EMC is delivering with this offer a definitive merger agreement to acquire all outstanding Data Domain common stock at $30.00 per share in cash.
  • This definitive merger agreement is substantially identical to the Data Domain/NetApp merger agreement already found acceptable to Data Domain’s Board of Directors, with no material changes other than our superior price except those changes necessary to accommodate a first-step tender offer which will expedite payment to Data Domain stockholders.
  • EMC is prepared to execute the merger agreement immediately upon Data Domain’s Board of Directors’ determination that EMC has made a Superior Proposal, as provided in the NetApp merger agreement. EMC’s merger agreement will then be subject to acceptance by Data Domain’s Board of Directors taking the necessary corporate action to authorize its execution on behalf of Data Domain, and such execution occurring.
  • EMC is not seeking any review of information from Data Domain in advance of Data Domain accepting EMC’s merger agreement, beyond what is publicly available, including what is reflected in the representations and warranties contained in the Data Domain/NetApp merger agreement. Nor is EMC requesting that Data Domain enter into discussions or negotiations with EMC. Accordingly, there is no need for EMC to enter into a confidentiality and standstill agreement with Data Domain.
  • Upon receipt of the EMC merger agreement, Data Domain’s Board of Directors will review it and, given its terms relative to the Data Domain/NetApp merger agreement, will determine that it constitutes a Superior Proposal and that the failure to change its recommendation is reasonably likely to be a breach of its fiduciary duties.
  • In connection with considering whether EMC’s merger agreement is a Superior Proposal, Data Domain will comply with all notice requirements under the Data Domain/NetApp merger agreement.
  • Upon determining that EMC’s merger agreement constitutes a Superior Proposal, Data Domain’s Board of Directors will immediately give NetApp five business days’ written notice of the details of EMC’s proposal and that Data Domain’s Board of Directors intends to terminate the Data Domain/NetApp merger agreement in favor of the EMC transaction.
  • At the end of the notice period, unless NetApp has made a proposal at least as favorable to Data Domain as the EMC merger agreement, Data Domain will determine that EMC’s offer continues to constitute a Superior Proposal and that the failure to terminate the NetApp merger agreement is reasonably likely to be a breach of its Board’s fiduciary duties under Delaware law and concurrently (1) terminate the Data Domain/NetApp merger agreement, (2) execute the EMC merger agreement and (3) pay to NetApp the termination fee.
  • EMC will continue its tender offer as provided in the merger agreement and the terms and conditions of the tender offer.

Comments

The reaction of EMC to the offering of NetApp to acquire Data Domain at this huge price is surprising since the storage leader is already in de-dupe with its own Avamar technology and with an OEM agreement with Quantum.

We only see two reasons for EMC to try to get Data Domain: 1/ to avoid one of its main competitor to get an excellent de-dupe product; or 2/ to oblige NetApp to put more dollars on the table to acquire Data Domain.

If the deal is done by EMC, Quantum could be in a bad position as its technology is comparable to Data Domain’s one, but with the possibility to be acquired later by... NetApp.

Read also:
NetApp Buys Data Domain for $1.5 Billion
 
A risky acquisition at this high price

 

Articles_bottom
ExaGrid
AIC
ATTOtarget="_blank"
OPEN-E